Chapter 3

Gallows & Generosities

~24 min read

Renn pushed off the wall and moved.

The city was still breathing. That was the thing about Khartha at this hour, it never quite stopped. Dockhands finishing late hauls. Merchants counting the day's damage. Lanterns coming on in windows above closed stalls, the city pulling inward rather than going dark. He moved through it with his hands in his pockets and his eyes doing what they always did, marking exits, clocking faces, reading the street the way you read weather.

The purse pressed against his ribs.

He didn't touch it.

He took the long way without deciding to. His feet knew the routes better than his head did and right now his head was somewhere he didn't want to follow. The long way kept him off the main quay, away from the dock guards and their habit of stopping boys who looked like they were carrying something. He cut through the sailmaker's quarter instead, narrow lanes that smelled of pitch and raw canvas, and came out the other side into the lower market where the stalls were shuttered but the taverns weren't.

Voices spilled out of an open door as he passed.

He didn't slow. Didn't need to.

"Thirteen now," someone was saying. "Not fifteen. Thirteen."

"They can't."

"They are."

Renn's jaw tightened. He kept walking.

He'd done his squire years. Seven to twelve, same as every boy in the Union who couldn't buy his way out of it. Drills and yes sir and the particular misery of armor that never fit right. He'd come back from it leaner and quieter and with a very clear understanding of what the Union thought boys were for.

That was before the forced conscription.

Thirteen to twenty now. Mandatory. No buying out unless you had the kind of coin that made laws flexible. Renn was seventeen and had neither the coin nor the patience and so he lived sideways of it, kept his head down, stayed off the census rolls the way you stayed off any list that could get you killed.

The street changed as he moved deeper into the residential tiers.

He traced through this part of the city like a finger down an old scar. The lanterns here were spaced differently. Warmer. More of them. Women in doorways who weren't waiting for the rain to pass.

He kept his eyes forward.

His mother had died on a street like this one. Not this street. One close enough that the difference didn't matter. He'd been twelve. Fifth year of squirehood, still two weeks from coming home, when the news found him through a letter that took longer to reach him than she had taken to die. A drunk. A john. The kind of violence that happened because it could and no one who mattered was watching.

He hadn't gotten to say anything.

Renn turned up a narrower lane and left it behind. Avoiding memories that offered nothing worth the finding. He'd gotten very good at it.

Elira's place sat above a cooper's shop that smelled of wet wood and old wine. The stairs were narrow and uneven. Renn took them without thinking, muscle memory carrying him up, and slowed at the landing and listened.

No shouting. No crying.

Good sign. Maybe.

He knocked. Not because he needed to. Just in case.

* * *

She opened the door before he knocked a second time.

That was Elira. Something in the pace and weight of his step. She seemed to hear him on the stairs even when he was trying not to be heard.

She looked at him and whatever she found there tightened around her eyes. Not angry yet. Just reading.

Her hair was pulled back, dark curls escaping despite the effort. She had a shawl pulled around her shoulders that he recognized as a gift he'd given her three years ago, worn thin at the edges now. There was a bruise fading along her collarbone, yellow at the edges, old enough that she hadn't bothered to cover it.

He saw it.

She noticed.

Neither said a word.

She stepped back and let him in.

Renn shrugged out of his jacket and hung it on the hook by the door. Carefully. It was her space. It had always been her space.

"You eaten?" she asked.

"Earlier."

She looked at him unconvinced.

"Something," he said.

She moved to the table and poured water into the second cup without asking and set it in front of the chair she wanted him to sit in. A moment later a wedge of hard cheese followed, set down the same way, no comment, no eye contact. Offered but not expecting.

He sat. She stood. That was how it usually went.

The cheese was hard and a little sour and the best thing he'd eaten all day.

He didn't say that. He just ate it slowly and drank the water and let the room settle around him.

It was small. Smaller than it deserved to be for everything it had to hold. The walls were clean deliberately, completely, the kind of clean that didn't happen by accident and wasn't only for him. A crack ran along the plaster above the window that hadn't been there last season. The sheet dividing his corner from hers was starting to fray at the hem where it pooled on the floor.

He'd been meaning to fix that.

He hadn't.

Candles burned on the sill and along the shelf above the basin, scent ones mostly, cheap wax and dried herbs doing what they could against the smell of the cooper's shop below. Wet wood and old wine rising through the floorboards.

He had hated it. He hated that he didn't any longer.

His eye caught the small shelf above the table.

A statue of Zephine, white stone worn smooth from handling, wings half spread, face tilted slightly down. In front of it a single candle, unlit, the wick still dark and curling from recent flame. A thin line of smoke rose from it, barely visible, bending toward the window and gone.

He knew what it meant.

He looked back at his cup.

Elira leaned against the wall with her arms folded and watched him finish the cheese.

"There's more," she said.

"I'm fine."

She didn't argue. She also didn't move.

He could feel her reading him. Not his face exactly, something behind it. She'd always been able to do that. Even when they were small, even before everything, she could look at him and know which kind of trouble he was in before he opened his mouth.

It made him feel like a child again. Somehow feeling relief and somehow unbearable all at once.

"You look tired," she said.

"I'm fine," he said again.

"You said that." She folded her arms across her chest.

Dammit.

He set the cup down.

She pushed off the wall and came to sit across from him, which meant this wasn't the standing kind of conversation. He kept his eyes on the table.

"I talked to Sera today," she said. Casually, despite the fact she had been probably considering it for hours. "She said her brother got pulled last week. Seventeen. Same as you."

Renn said nothing.

"They didn't ask him," Elira continued. "Just came to the door. Had his name written down somewhere."

"They don't have my name written down anywhere."

"You don't know that."

He looked up then. "Elira."

"I'm not arguing with you," she said. "I'm just saying what I know."

She wasn't arguing. That was the thing about her. She didn't argue. She just laid things down in front of you like stones and let you trip over them yourself.

He looked back at the table.

The crack in the plaster caught his eye again. He was going to fix that. He was going to fix a lot of things.

She let the silence sit for a moment, then:

"Malic asked about you."

Renn's hands stilled on the cup.

Fat cunt.

"He says you haven't been by in a few weeks."

"I've been busy."

"With what?" She let out a small chuckle. Not unkind. Just knowing.

"Work."

Elira looked at him, hands going to her hips. "What work."

It wasn't a question. That was the way she asked it. It never quite was.

"Street work," he said. "Same as always."

She nodded slowly, like she was filing that away somewhere she'd return to later. "He said men stop coming to him when they owe someone else."

There it is.

"Malic worries too much," Renn said. "And talks even more, apparently."

"Malic's been in this city longer than either of us have been alive." She pulled the other chair out and sat down across from him properly now, elbows on the table. "He doesn't worry without a reason."

Renn looked at his cup.

"Elira, I—"

"How long have you been short."

Fuck.

He turned the cup in his hands. The wood of the table had a scratch running across it that hadn't been there last month. He wondered how it got there and then stopped wondering because it didn't matter and thinking about it was easier than answering her.

"A while," he said finally.

She exhaled through her nose. Not anger. The thing before anger when you've been expecting something and it still lands wrong.

"What happens when the knock comes," she said, "and it's not you on the other side of it."

Renn said nothing.

"I've already lost one person to this city." Her voice didn't waver. That was worse than if it had. "When people owe in this city, it's not always the one who owes who ends up doing the paying in the end."

He looked at the table.

"I know," he said.

"Do you?"

It wasn't cruel. It wasn't even angry. It was just a question she actually wanted answered and didn't expect him to answer honestly and they both knew it and sat with it anyway.

He was quiet for long enough that the cooper's shop filled the silence for him.

"I'll go see Malic," he said finally. "Tomorrow."

Elira looked at him.

"I will," he said. "I swear it."

"I know you will," she said. "You always mean it when you say it."

He couldn't tell if that was forgiveness or an indictment. With her it was sometimes both at once.

She stood and took his cup and set it by the basin without making it a thing. Her way of saying the conversation was done without saying it. He recognized it instantly. The specific language of someone you've shared a life with whether you chose to or not.

Renn stood. Reached for his jacket.

She was already at the shelf.

He watched her take the candle from in front of the small stone Zephine, cup her hand around the wick, and light it from the taper she kept on the basin. The flame caught small and steady. She looked at it for a moment, lips moving without sound, and then she blew it out.

The smoke rose thin and straight and bent toward the window and was gone.

She turned back to him.

"I'll ask her to put favorable winds at your back," she said. "For whatever you're carrying." She paused. "It helped me. After. More than I expected it to."

Renn looked at the dead wick. The smoke already gone.

He thought about his mother on a street two blocks from a shrine just like this one. He thought about the thing Elira had lost six months ago, the one she never named out loud, that never got to be anything at all. He thought about smoke drifting toward a window and a god who owned the wind in this city and had never once used it to stop anything that mattered.

The words were right there.

He swallowed them.

"Yeah," he said.

She looked at him for a moment. Then nodded once, deciding to believe it whether she trusted it or not.

"Come back tonight," she said. "Not tomorrow. Tonight."

He held her gaze.

"Yeah," he said again.

He meant it when he said it.

He put on his jacket and walked out the door and down the narrow uneven stairs and back into Khartha, which was still there, indifferent to all of it.

* * *

Vael's Vigil had settled over the city by the time he hit the street.

Rhea and Oberon were down, their light gone, and only Vael remained, small and pale green and constant above the rooftops. Not bright enough to see by. Just enough to know the sky was still there. The city looked different under it. Harder. More honest about what it was.

He moved close to the buildings, steps light on the stone, eyes doing what they always did. The streets had thinned to the kind of sparse that made you visible. He navigated it the way he always did, corners checked, doorways noted, the two guard posts on the direct route avoided without thinking about it.

He heard the patrol before he saw it. Two sets of boots, unhurried, the rhythm of men not looking for anything specific but willing to find something if it presented itself. Renn stepped into a recessed doorway and went still.

They passed without slowing.

He counted to twenty anyway. Then moved.

He took the longer route. Past the stripped shrine with the blackened alcoves. Across the narrow footbridge over water that had stopped moving sometime last season. Through the cut between the old granary and the tanner's yard where the smell was bad enough that nobody lingered.

Nobody lingered meant nobody watching.

He came out the other side onto the street he needed and felt it then.

Not the Gallowknives. He knew what that felt like. This was something else. Heavier. More patient. The kind of attention that didn't need to get close because it wasn't in a hurry. He checked. Doorways. Reflections in dark shop glass. The mouth of an alley across the street holding itself too quiet.

Nothing.

The feeling didn't move.

The building sat in the middle of the industrial district, three stories of dark stone with its windows lit against the night, the smell reaching him half a block before anything else did. Dye. Lye. The particular sharp bite of chemical treatment that made your eyes water if you breathed it wrong. Above the main door the Union's own colors hung drying in Vael's light. Dark blue and grey, turning slowly.

He circled the block once. Not ritual this time. Actually looking. Watching the gaps between carts, the mouths of alleys, the particular stillness of doorways that held themselves too quiet. He came back around to the front and found nothing and didn't feel better about it.

He was going to go around again.

The wind shifted off the harbor. Just a breath of it. Warm against the back of his neck where the night air had no business being warm.

He went in.

The factory floor hit him immediately. Noise first, the low steady industry of work that didn't stop for the hour, workers moving between long tables under hanging lanterns, cloth pulled through treatments in sequence, folded, stacked, moved on. Nobody looked up. That was part of it too. You learned not to notice who came through and the learning stuck.

The smell was worse inside. It lived in the walls.

He crossed the factory floor without hurrying and pushed through the heavy door at the back.

The noise dropped. The smell changed underneath itself, the chemical bite still there but something else beneath it now. Woodsmoke. Tallow. Spilled drink soaked into old boards.

The bar was small and deliberately so. A counter, bottles behind it that didn't advertise themselves, four tables with the kind of chairs that had been repaired enough times they'd stopped looking like any one thing. Lanterns turned low. The whole space designed to hold conversation without letting it out.

The Gallowknives were at the table nearest the back wall.

Of course they were.

Kerris saw him first.

She was leaning back in her chair with her arms crossed, that mouth of hers sitting just short of a smile the way it always did, like she was waiting for something she already knew was coming. Lean. Dark haired, worn practical and short. A thin scar ran along her jaw that she'd stopped thinking about years ago. Her eyes were already slightly ahead of him when he walked through the door.

Kalm sat beside her, big in the loose way that looked soft until it didn't, light eyes flat and disinterested in the low light. The coin was already moving across his knuckles without him looking at it.

Sorn sat a step behind them both. Pale. Thin. The kind of face you'd forget the moment you looked away. He wasn't looking at Renn. He was looking at the space around Renn the way you looked at weather before it arrived.

Renn crossed to the bar and put his back to them.

The barman looked at him. Said nothing.

"Whatever's least likely to kill me," Renn said. "And don't make me work for it."

A cup appeared. He picked it up and turned around.

Kerris hadn't moved. "Renn," she said pleasantly. "Thought you might not show tonight."

"Thought you might not be breathin'," Renn said. "Funny how the city keeps disappointin' us both."

Kalm's coin slowed.

Kerris tilted her head. "That's a hell of a thing to say to people you owe."

"I owe Rook," Renn said. "Not you lot. Last I checked you were just drinkin' his ale."

Kerris smiled wider. "Heard you've had a rough few months. Bad luck followin' you around."

"Bad luck," Renn said. "Sure."

"You don't believe in bad luck?"

"I do. By the ten, I do." Renn took a sip. "I just like to know whose bloody face it's wearin'."

Something moved behind Kerris's eyes. She leaned back, easy, like a woman settling into a conversation she'd been looking forward to. "You know the Merchant's Row job? Three months back."

Renn went still.

"Good score," she continued. "Clean location. Should've been easy for a careful lad." She paused. "Heard someone got there first. Cleared it out before the interested party could make his move. Left just enough of a mess that the watch came sniffin' around." The smile didn't shift. "Bad luck that."

"Aye, bad luck indeed," Kalm said, grin rising slow.

The cup in Renn's hand didn't move.

"That was you," Renn said.

"Den doesn't assign territory," Kerris said pleasantly. "You know that. First come, first bloody served."

Renn looked at her. Then at Kalm. Then at Sorn who hadn't moved or spoken and was watching with the flat patience of something that had already decided.

"You burned the job," Renn said. "And left me holdin' the mess."

"We were motivated," Kalm said. Flat. Bored. Like the conversation was beneath him but he'd shown up anyway.

"Thorough," added Kerris.

"Right that," Kalm said slowly. "Thorough."

"Motivated," Renn repeated. "Right." The heat was climbing his chest now. "You know what that cost me? The months—"

"Nope," Kerris cut in. "Nor do we fuckin' care."

"Not our problem," Kalm said.

"No. Course not. Nothin's ever your problem is it." Renn looked at Kerris. "You just drift around makin' other people's problems worse and call it work. That how you explain it to yourselves? Just business?"

Kerris's smile thinned at the edges. Just slightly. "Careful Renn. Could end up floatin' by the pier."

"Floatin'," added Kalm.

"I've been bloody careful," Renn said. "Careful's what got me here. Maybe I should try somethin' else." He set his cup down, hand reaching behind his back slowly. "You want to know what I think? I think you hit that job because you couldn't take it clean yourselves and watchin' me drown was the next best thing. I think Rook keeps you around because you're useful and the day that changes he won't remember your fuckin' names."

Sorn's eyes dropped to his hand.

That was worse than anything the other two had said.

Kalm was on his feet. Kerris's hand stopped him from coming forward, a smile crawling its way back across her face which was the most frightening thing that had happened yet. The hand at Sorn's side had shifted in a way that wasn't casual anymore.

"You've got a mouth on you," Kerris said quietly. "Always have. I've been patient about it."

"Patient," Renn said. "That what we're callin' it."

"I'm callin' it done," she said.

The room had gone very quiet.

Kerris took one step forward.

The door at the back of the bar opened.

One of Rook's men leaned through it, looked at the room, looked at Renn.

"He's ready for you," he said.

Nobody moved.

Renn picked up his cup, finished what was left in it, and set it back down.

"Gentlemen," he said.

He walked to the door without hurrying and without looking back.

He should have looked back.

* * *

Renn walked through the door and Rook was already looking at him.

He sat behind a table that had seen better decades, a ledger open in front of him, a cup at his elbow that had been refilled recently enough that the smell of it reached Renn before he'd fully crossed the threshold. Slim. Sharp featured. Hair cut close to the skull. The candlelight caught the earrings and the pale ruin of his left eye, the scar running through it old and settled, and where his shirt sat open at the chest the edges of Trivain ink showed, solid dark blocks that had blurred slightly at the edges with age.

Brannic Holt stood to the left of the table. Broad. Thick through the chest and shoulders. The scar splitting his scalp caught the light the same way it always did, pale and jagged, like the wound had been in a hurry. His arms were folded. His face said nothing. It never did.

"Renn my boy." Rook gestured at the chair across from him like they were old friends settling in for a long evening. "Come. Sit, sit."

Renn sat.

"Rook always has time for you lad." Rook leaned back, comfortable, fingers laced across his stomach. "Especially when my money is involved." The good eye settled on him. The ruined one looked somewhere else entirely. "You do have my money lad?"

Not quite asking. More implying he better.

"Yes," Renn said. "Not all of it."

He tossed the purse on the table.

Rook looked at it for a moment without touching it. Then he reached out and lifted it by the drawstring, let it dangle, bounced it once feeling the weight of it. He raised it to eye level and looked at Renn through it, the coins shifting inside, his expression somewhere between amused and disappointed in the way only a man completely in control of the situation could manage both at once.

"This feels..." He set it down gently. "Well. Let's just say it's not quite what I was expecting."

"The Gallowknives," Renn started. "They burned the Merchant's Row job. Three months back. Set me up and cleared it before I could get there and left enough of a mess that the watch—"

"That's den business," Rook said pleasantly, continuing like Renn hadn't spoken at all. He picked up the purse and shook it once, the coins shifting. "This is my business."

Renn closed his mouth.

"The Gallowknives are den business lad. What happens between members stays between members. Rook doesn't arbitrate squabbles." He set the cup down. "You know why?"

Renn didn't answer.

"Struggle builds character," Rook said, gesturing generously with one hand. "Not five minutes ago you were out there thinkin' about pullin' a blade on those three." He paused. "I don't recommend it mind you. Sorn alone would have you in the harbor before you cleared the scabbard." He waved that aside. "But you thought about it. That counts for something."

Brannic made a sound.

"Thirty years ago," Rook continued, leaning back further, settling into it, "I'd have been in your shoes and done the same. Fought groups of four or five plenty in those days." A pause. A sip. "Won too."

Renn looked at him.

"Four or five," Renn said.

"At least," Rook said pleasantly.

Silence sat between them for a moment. Rook let it. He was a man who had made peace with silence long ago.

"This is light," he said finally, nodding at the purse. "Even for my generosity. And you'll find that generosity is wearing thin lad. It has its limits same as everything else."

"If you give me—"

"Now." Rook leaned forward, elbows on the table, the candlelight catching the pale scar across his blind eye. "If it hadn't been for me knowing your mother—"

Renn went still.

"Grew up with her," Rook continued, unhurried, like Renn hadn't spoken at all. "Pleasant woman. In spite of her trade." Something moved across his face that wasn't quite sentiment but lived next door to it. "Damn shame what happened to her."

He paused. Let it settle.

"That being said it's what stopped me from having Brannic here kick in your sister's door and make a mess of things."

Brannic said nothing. He didn't need to.

"Don't you see?" Rook leaned back, crossing his arms, satisfied in the way of a man who has thought well of himself for a very long time and found no reason to stop. "I am generous. Quite generous all things considered."

Brannic made a sound in his chest that passed for agreement.

Renn looked at the table. His mind was moving in six directions at once and none of them had anywhere to land. His mother. Rook knew his mother. Grew up with her. There were questions behind that he couldn't begin to count and not a single one of them was getting answered tonight.

He filed it away. He had to.

"Two weeks," Rook said.

Renn looked up.

Rook was watching him with those careful eyes, the good one and the ruined one both, like he could read the calculation happening behind Renn's face and found it interesting.

"Two weeks," he repeated. "Clear the balance. All of it." He tilted his head. "You thought I'd give you one."

Renn had thought he'd be lucky to get one.

"You're right," Rook said pleasantly. "I could have. But I didn't." He spread his hands. "Generous."

Renn exhaled slowly. Two weeks. Jory's plan sitting in his chest felt different suddenly. Not comfortable. But possible.

"Two weeks," Renn said.

"Every crown," Rook said. The pleasantness didn't shift but something underneath it did. Just slightly. Just enough. "I liked your mother lad. I like you. That only carries so far."

He picked up his cup and leaned back.

The meeting was over.

Renn stood. He had nothing to reach for. The purse stayed on the table.

"Rook," he said.

Rook looked at him over the rim of his cup.

"My mother," Renn said. "We'll talk about that."

Rook smiled. Slow. Genuine. Not entirely pleasant.

"Two weeks lad," he said. "Let's see where we are after that."

Renn turned for the door.

"And lad."

He stopped.

Rook hadn't moved from his chair. Hadn't looked up from the cup in his hand.

"Do be careful out there," he said pleasantly. "Reaching for your blade against Kerris is just as bad for your health as pulling it my boy."

Brannic opened the door.

Renn walked out into the bar and through it and back through the factory floor and out into Khartha where Vael's Vigil held the city in its pale light and the wind was still moving through the streets, belonging to whoever claimed it.

He didn't look back at the Gallowknives table.

He should have.